So as we continue on down this excursion through Album Ranking Lane, we take a left turn from the music we have so far covered and arrive in the wonderful synth enthused world that is Erasure. Formed in 1985 when Andy Bell responded to Vince Clarke’s advert in Melody Maker. Vince had previous been known for his work in Depeche Mode and Yazoo while for Andy Bell, this was his first big success in the music world. After an initial struggle to get their songs to chart, the boys soon hit the bigtime in 1986 with Sometimes and from then on they continued producing hits and continue to do to this day. The band are also known for their popularity in the LGBT community, as Andy Bell is a proud gay man and continues to do work for several charities in the community.
Erasure were one of the first bands I got into when I was younger and continue to be one of the most played artists in my collection. I’ve seen them several times live throughout the years, usually with one of my oldest friends and fellow music lover Gav and together we have recorded covers of some of the bands tracks to scratch that musical itch when we can’t get to a concert.
So as usual we shall be counting down the studio output from the boys, however as usual, there are a few exceptions to the rule and they are as follows: Union Street – an acoustic album of reworkings of previous recorded songs and Snow Globe, an album of Christmas recordings of some seasonal classics along with some newly penned numbers. No EP’s are being included here, so Crackers International and Abba-esque won’t be found on this trip. With that said, let’s start our countdown….
17. Loveboat
We begin our trip with 2000’s Loveboat. An album that brought more guitars than synths to the show and as such, didn’t get as much usual traction with the fanbase. Not horrific, but not a great place to start your Erasure listening journey. It is noted that at the time, Andy was going through a lot of issues relating to his health and his partner suffering a stroke. As such, the pain and feeling does resonate through the album as a whole. That being said, there are a few standout tracks here to enjoy
Favourite Tracks: Freedom, Alien, Here In My Heart
Least Favourite Track: Surreal
16. World Be Gone
We take a jump forward in time for our next entry, with the number sixteen slot being filled by 2017’s World Be Gone. Marking a more synth based sound than our previous entry, the band are more like their old selves here. Better received and more accessible, it’s certainly not a bad album, but for me, there’s not as many likeable songs to keep coming back to.
Favourite Tracks: Love You to the Sky, World Be Gone, Oh What A World
Least Favourite Track: Take Me Out Of Myself
15. Light At The End Of The World
We take another jump in time, this time a decade backwards from our last entry with 2007’s Light At The End Of The World. With upbeat synth work ahoy, this is a more rounded work than our earlier entries, but again suffers from a lack of consistency through the record. A strong start seems to tail off towards the end, leaving the feeling of what could have been.
Favourite Tracks: Sunday Girl, I Could Fall In Love With You, Storm In A Teacup
Least Favourite Track: Darlene
14. Other People’s Songs
We remain in the 2000’s with our next entrant, 2003’s Other People’s Songs. This is a covers album with all the songs chosen being ones that influenced Andy and Vince in their musical upbringing and careers. While not exactly an original idea, it’s a fun little work through some classic tunes from yesteryear with a few that stand out for re-listening. It would also mark the first time since 1994, that the band had a single in the UK top ten.
Favourite Tracks: Solsbury Hill, Make Me Smile (Come Up and See Me), Video Killed The Radiostar
Least Favourite Track: Ebb Tide
13. Day-Glo (Based On A True Story)
Up next we find ourselves in the present, with our number 13 being 2022’s Day-Glo. This is a somewhat unique album, in that it takes the musical stems from the previous album, The Neon, and tweaks and rearranges them into new tracks. More of a leftfield outing than straightforward synth pop outing, this is one for the curios, but very much one worth listening to for the whole soundscape presented.
Favourite Tracks: Bop Beat, Now, Inside Out
Least Favourite Track: Harbour of My Heart
12. Cowboy
We take our first trip back into the 1990’s now with our number twelve, 1997’s Cowboy. The subsequent tour for this album was the first time that I saw Erasure live, at the good old Brighton Centre. It was also memorable for seeing Vince dressed up as a giant cactus whilst playing guitar! A very much pop orientated album here with several tracks that stand out and led to decent sales. Worth a revisit and picking some of their late 90’s work for reappraisal.
Favourite Tracks: In My Arms, Don’t Say Your Love Is Killing Me, Boy, Love Affair, Rain
Least Favourite Track: Treasure
11. The Violet Flame
We jump forward again, this time to 2014, with The Violet Flame. In a first, all the tracks were produced on synthesizers rather than guitar and piano as had been the usual song writing practice for the boys. With a distinctive upbeat electronic sound, in part to Richard X’s co-production, there’s plenty of pumping beats to open the album, but does suffer a similar vein of tailing off in quality before the end. Some good tunes to pick out though to get you up for a dance though.
Favourite Tracks: Dead of Night, Elevation, Reason, Sacred
Least Favourite Track: Be The One
10. Tomorrow’s World
As we crack the top 10, we are presented with 2011’s Tomorrow’s World. Bringing a vibrant and buzzy tone, in part due to Frankmusik who produced the album ,the boys are on form with catchy, upbeat numbers that you can put the headphones on and slip into a delightfully poppy world. Certainly a good way to start the 2010’s, it was great to see live on the subsequent tour, with several tracks making the playlist. Lots of hooky goodness here for you to enjoy.
Favourite Tracks: Be with You, Fill Us With Fire, A Whole Lotta Love Run Riot, When I Start To (Break It All Down), I Lose Myself
Least Favourite Track: What Will I Say When You’re Gone?
9. I Say I Say I Say
Our number nine entry brings back to 1994 with Erasure’s sixth album, I Say I Say I Say. On the back of their first ever UK number one single, in 1992’s Abba-esque EP, the boys continued their strong performance, with another album that topped the charts and delivered several notable singles that had plenty of air play. Some big tunes on here to enjoy and deserve repeat listening, for me as a whole, the album ebbs and flows into good and great tracks, a little more consistency and this would probably be much higher up the list.
Favourite Tracks: Always, I Love Saturday, Run To The Sun, Blues Away
Least Favourite Track: So The Story Goes
8. Wild!
Our first appearance of 80’s Erasure somewhat cleverly finds us with our number eight entry, 1989’s Wild! Following on the trails of a highly successful run of albums and singles, Wild! continues this with several classic Erasure tracks that remain firm fan favourites today and constantly in live setlists. Although not as well received upon release, it still sold in the bucket load and was certified double platinum. With what seems to have been a continuing factor, consistency throughout lets this one down a bit. Whilst packing several big hitters in the bands catalogue, some numbers let the team down a bit. But take the big ones and you’re in for an audible treat.
Favourite Tracks: Blue Savannah, Drama!, Star, You Surround Me, Piano Song
Least Favourite Track: Crown of Thorns
7. The Neon
Our magnificent number seven is 2020’s The Neon. In an attempt to recapture the old sound, Andy and Vince used older synths and a different approach to writing, recording more than the usual ten tracks they made for each album and letting the label choose the tracks for the release. A very solid record across the board that ticks a lot of boxes. Toured the following year given it’s release in the midst of the pandemic, it’s an album that I think will draw more playback over the coming years. Lots to enjoy here.
Favourite Tracks: Shot a Satellite, Hey Now (Think I Got a Feeling), Nerves Of Steel, Fallen Angel, Kid You’re Not Alone, Careful What I Try to Do
Least Favourite Track: New Horizons
6. The Circus
Our number six entry is the band’s 1987 sophomore album, The Circus. After the initial reaction to their debut album fell a bit flat given Vince’s reputation from his work in Depeche Mode and Yazoo, the boys looked to up their game and show the world what they really could do. What they created was considered an improvement and helped deliver them their first top 10 album along with their first singles to break the top 10 in the singles chart. Setting a tone for their future releases, vibrant tunes abound but also an emotional depth is clearly visible in the lyrics. It’s success spawned a further release titled The Two Ring Circus, which was composed of new remixes and rearrangements along with a bunch of live tracks. This is one circus that’s well worth the admission.
Favourite Tracks: Victim Of Love, Sometimes, It Doesn’t Have To Be, Hideaway, The Circus, Spiralling
Least Favourite Track: If I Could
5. Nightbird
As we draw closer to the end of our countdown, we find ourselves at number five, and 2005’s Nightbird. After the poorly received Loveboat and adventures in covers with Other People’s Songs, Erasure come back storming with an emotional record, given shortly before release Andy informed the world he was HIV positive, which certainly made a lot of people and critics view the music and lyrics in a more deeper way than perhaps they would’ve done. Though again receiving mixed reviews critically, fans bought into the album and sighted it as a return to form given the past few recordings. There are plenty of great tunes here to take away and delve deep into the music, at time of release, this was constant during some difficult times for me mentally.
Favourite Tracks: Here I Go Impossible Again, Breathe, All This Time Still Falling Out of Love, I Bet You’re Mad At Me, Don’t Say You Love Me
Least Favourite Track: No Doubt
4. Chorus
Our number four entry is the first album Erasure released in the 1990’s with 1991’s Chorus. Continuing a run of number one albums (Their third consecutively at the time of release), the boys continue their rich run of form with an album chock full of awesome tunes that hit you with upbeat melodies and fantastic vocal performances. With several successful singles coming off the album, it’s an album that continues to be at the forefront of their back catalogue. Deserving of multiple listens through from top to bottom.
Favourite Tracks: Love To Hate You, Breath Of Life, Chorus, Am I Right?, Siren Song, Home
Least Favourite Track: Perfect Stranger
3. Wonderland
In the bronze medal position, we find ourselves at the very beginning, with 1986’s Wonderland. As we touched on earlier with The Circus, Wonderland was not initially well received upon release, which in my opinion is a shame as to me, it’s a great introduction to the band, packed with the sort of tunes that would become the staple of the band’s output in the 1980’s. Though it didn’t chart well in the UK, it did fare much better in mainland Europe. As such, this success was used when the band re-released their first single with a new “Hamburg Mix” in 1992, which did significantly better in the charts (hitting number 10 than the previously effort of number 55 when released to promote the POP! compilation album). I still have this on cassette and more than likely had worn the tape out given the number of listen throughs throughout the years. So take a trip down the rabbit hole and lose yourself in some pop loveliness.
Favourite Tracks: Who Needs Love Like That, Cry So Easy, Heavenly Action, Oh L’Amour, My Heart…So Blue
Least Favourite Track: Say What
2. Erasure
In the runners up spot, we find ourselves back in the 1990’s with 1995’s self-titled album Erasure taking the silver. In what would be deemed a left turn from their previous efforts, this album moves away from the upbeat pop of their usual style and moves into more mid tempo and thoughtful, reflective songs that all were more than five minutes in length, again something that was out of the ordinary. But as a result, you have an album that draws you in and takes you on a musical adventure that keeps you invested throughout and leaves you yearning for more after it finishes. The lyrics and melodies are soulful and delivered with excellence by both Andy and Vince, as well as appearances from the London Community Gospel Choir. This is one that needs your attention and as such, you’ll find yourself well rewarded.
Favourite Tracks: Rock Me Gently, Stay With Me, Rescue Me, Fingers & Thumbs (Cold Summer’s Day), I Love You
Least Favourite Track: Grace
1. The Innocents
And here we are at the peak, the definitive, the very best of the bunch. At number one, we have 1988’s The Innocents, ultimately deemed the bands first major success in the UK with it topping the album charts for the first time in their career. Built on the ground work of their first two albums, the band reached the apex here and ultimately gave us their most well known song in A Little Respect, an anthem that still inspires mass singalongs to this day (and a rather fun cover by Wheatus!) It remains their biggest selling album to date and it’s not hard to see why. Packed with almighty pop bangers and songs of yearning, it’s an album that takes it’s hooks and buries them in your brain so you’re humming them still much later on down the line. Easily the most consistent album of their career, there is a lot to enjoy and take away here and replay to your hearts content.
Favourite Tracks: A Little Respect, Ship Of Fools, Chains Of Love, Heart Of Stone, Yahoo!, Imagination, Weight Of The World, Phantom Bride
Least Favourite Track: Sixty-Five Thousand
So here we are at the end of another jovial journey through the discography of the wonderful Erasure. I hope you’ve enjoyed this one as much as I had in writing it and getting to back through my entire catalogue again. I shall return again with some more rankings for your listening pleasure, so until then my friends…